Lesson 12 of 32 · Part One, the principles
The Council of Invisible Counselors
A single answer, however well written, is one point of view - and usually the most agreeable one. Instead of asking what you should do, name three or four people with genuinely opposed stakes in the matter - an investor, an accountant, a customer, a rival - and make the machine argue the question out as each of them in turn. The value is not in the advice but in the disagreement, because that is where your blind spots are sitting.
How to use The Council of Invisible Counselors in Claude
Give each voice its own tag and the council stops blurring into one. Put your situation, the decision and the roster in tags at the top, and the actual instruction at the very bottom, where Claude follows it most reliably. Two habits are worth building in. Ask for its own reasoning before the debate - three or four lines on which advisor it expects to be right - because that is the part you can argue with. And tell it what to do when an advisor is being polite instead of honest: have it flag the soft line and give the harder version underneath. Keep your standing council in a Project's instructions and every chat in that Project convenes it without being asked.
- One tag per advisor - the roster stops collapsing into one voice.
- Roster and context first, the instruction last.
- Ask for its own reasoning before the debate, so you can argue with it.
From GenAI for Everyone: Prompt Engineering Handbook, First Edition 2025, by Raja Rajeshwari Seshadri and Shreeram Iyer.
Give each voice its own tag and the council stops blurring into one. Put your situation, the decision and the roster in tags at the top, and the actual instruction at the very bottom, where Claude follows it most reliably. Two habits are worth building in. Ask for its own reasoning before the debate - three or four lines on which advisor it expects to be right - because that is the part you can argue with. And tell it what to do when an advisor is being polite instead of honest: have it flag the soft line and give the harder version underneath. Keep your standing council in a Project's instructions and every chat in that Project convenes it without being asked.
From the book Create a Project with standing instructions such as "Always give me a debate between a supporter, a critic and a neutral expert," so every chat in it convenes your council automatically.
- One tag per advisor - the roster stops collapsing into one voice.
- Roster and context first, the instruction last.
- Ask for its own reasoning before the debate, so you can argue with it.
- Tell it to flag any advisor being polite instead of honest.
- Keep the standing council in a Project's instructions.
Instead of
What are the benefits of a free plan?
Claude version
<my_situation> Two founders and four employees in Bengaluru, no outside investment. Our app lets coaching centres track fee collection and attendance. About 40 centres pay us today, most of them in tier-2 towns in Karnataka and Telangana. Server and SMS costs rise with every centre on the platform, whether it pays or not. </my_situation> <the_decision> Make the app free for the first year to every new coaching centre that signs up. </the_decision> <council> <advisor seat="growth investor" protects="the shape of our user curve" /> <advisor seat="chartered accountant" protects="our bank balance in month nine" /> <advisor seat="coaching-centre owner, pays us every month" protects="her own sense of having got a fair deal" /> <advisor seat="founder of our nearest competitor" protects="his market share, and would enjoy our failure" /> </council> <debate_rules> Every advisor takes a side. No balanced positions. In the second round each answers, by name, the strongest objection raised against them. Where an advisor is being polite instead of honest, mark the line [soft] and write underneath what that person would actually say to their own colleagues about us. </debate_rules> <task> First, four lines of your own reasoning: which advisor do you expect to turn out right, and why? I want to argue with that before the debate starts. Then run both rounds. Then an Artifact holding the three biggest risks as a table - risk, who raised it, what it costs us, the earliest warning sign - and one recommendation. </task>
Then loop it
- The accountant's server-cost objection is still standing. Have the investor answer it in the same Artifact, with arithmetic. If the arithmetic does not work, say so instead of arguing around it.
- Add a middle path to the debate - a 90-day free trial rather than a free year - and let the same four argue it for one round. Tell me if any of them is now just agreeing with me.
- Settled. Rewrite this whole prompt, tags and all, with blanks for [the decision] and [the four seats], so I can save it as the instructions of a Project called "Advisory council".
Why it worksFour named counsellors with different interests reveal blind spots that a single "benefits" answer would hide.
Instead of
Should I move to Pune after retirement?
Claude version
<us> I am 66, a retired army officer, living in Dehradun with my wife. We have been here thirty years. Her friends, her temple and her walking group are all within a kilometre of our gate. My pension is fixed and does not grow. </us> <them> Our daughter lives in Pune with her husband and our two grandchildren. She has asked us to move. </them> <the_question> Should we leave Dehradun and settle in Pune? </the_question> <council> <voice who="my wife" stake="the thirty years of friendship she would be leaving" /> <voice who="our daughter" stake="wanting us close, and working out who will care for whom" /> <voice who="a fee-only financial planner" stake="a fixed pension meeting a dearer city" /> <voice who="a retired officer who stayed in Dehradun" stake="has watched friends leave, and some come back" /> </council> <must_cover> Cost of living. Healthcare access. Climate. Community. Our independence from our daughter's household. </must_cover> <if_unsure> Where you do not know something about either city, say so rather than filling it in. Mark it [we must check this] and I will find out myself. </if_unsure> <task> Give me, for each voice, the strongest case for the move and the strongest case against, written in that person's own words. Argue both sides at full strength, including the side you think is wrong. Recommend nothing. Then end with the eight questions my wife and I should answer together before we decide - the uncomfortable ones. </task>
Then loop it
- My wife's fear of losing her friends outweighs everything else here. Ask the council what couples in our position have actually done about it, and have the daughter answer her mother directly rather than reassuring her.
- Put the final for-and-against points in an Artifact as a two-column table we can print and write on.
Why it worksHearing every side - including the voices of family - protects him from only seeing the facet he already favours.
Instead of
Is switching to banana leaves good for the temple?
Claude version
<the_setting> A temple trust in Madurai. Ten-day festival. Annadanam for roughly 3,000 people a day, served in about ninety minutes at each sitting, currently on plastic-coated paper plates. I am a volunteer, not a trustee - I can propose, not decide. </the_setting> <the_plan> Switch the whole festival to banana leaves. </the_plan> <council> <stakeholder who="head cook" loses_if="service slows down or the leaves arrive wet and unwashed" /> <stakeholder who="trust treasurer" loses_if="the cost rises or a new supplier fails mid-festival" /> <stakeholder who="municipal sanitation officer" loses_if="the waste is heavier and nobody has arranged for it" /> <stakeholder who="banana farmer from a nearby village" loses_if="he commits to peak-day volumes he cannot cut" /> <stakeholder who="devotee of forty years" loses_if="the custom changes in a way that feels wrong to her" /> </council> <task> Round one: each stakeholder states their position in under 100 words and names the one thing that would make them refuse outright. Round two: an agreement matrix as a table - the five as rows, with columns for Agrees on, Clashes with whom, Would walk away if. No empty cells. Round three: the smallest set of changes that would let the plan survive all five objections. Argue the cook and the treasurer without mercy. If the honest answer is that this collapses on day six when 4,000 people arrive, let them say exactly that, and tell me which of them is right. </task>
Then loop it
- The treasurer does not trust the supply on peak days. Put him and the farmer alone together and have them negotiate a real arrangement - advance order, buffer stock, a second village - with the weak point of that arrangement named.
- Now write the agreed plan as a one-page note in Tamil for the trust committee meeting, as an Artifact, with cost and supply stated plainly and nothing left vague.
Why it worksGiving the critics a seat at the table finds the weak points - supply, cost, waste - before the festival, not during it.
Questions
What is The Council of Invisible Counselors in prompt engineering?
A single answer, however well written, is one point of view - and usually the most agreeable one. Instead of asking what you should do, name three or four people with genuinely opposed stakes in the matter - an investor, an accountant, a customer, a rival - and make the machine argue the question out as each of them in turn. The value is not in the advice but in the disagreement, because that is where your blind spots are sitting.
When should I use this technique?
When you have half decided something expensive or hard to reverse, and what you actually need is the strongest case against it before you commit.
How do I apply it in Claude?
Give each voice its own tag and the council stops blurring into one. Put your situation, the decision and the roster in tags at the top, and the actual instruction at the very bottom, where Claude follows it most reliably. Two habits are worth building in. Ask for its own reasoning before the debate - three or four lines on which advisor it expects to be right - because that is the part you can argue with. And tell it what to do when an advisor is being polite instead of honest: have it flag the soft line and give the harder version underneath. Keep your standing council in a Project's instructions and every chat in that Project convenes it without being asked.
What are the limits of this technique in Claude?
Claude is agreeable, and an agreeable council is a useless one. Its critic tends to arrive courteous, conceding your point before making its own, which feels like balance and is actually capitulation. Say so directly: "the competitor is not here to be fair - give me what he would say to his own team about us." Watch too for four advisors who all share Claude's own judgement in different registers; the test is whether any of them says something you did not want to hear. If none does, the debate has not happened yet.
How do I improve the answer after the first try?
After the first debate, check whether every counsellor actually disagreed, or whether they all politely said the same thing. If the debate feels soft, say "Make the critic tougher - give the strongest argument against." Then pick the point of greatest conflict and ask two counsellors to argue it out. Finally, ask for a synthesis: "Where do they agree, and what is the wisest path?" Save a council you like, so you can call the same experts again next time.
Loop it
After the first debate, check whether every counsellor actually disagreed, or whether they all politely said the same thing. If the debate feels soft, say "Make the critic tougher - give the strongest argument against." Then pick the point of greatest conflict and ask two counsellors to argue it out. Finally, ask for a synthesis: "Where do they agree, and what is the wisest path?" Save a council you like, so you can call the same experts again next time.
This lesson on the other tools
The technique is the same; the way you write it is not. ChatGPT, Gemini.Perplexity.