Lesson 12 of 32 · Part One, the principles
The Council of Invisible Counselors
A single answer, however well written, is one point of view - and usually the most agreeable one. Instead of asking what you should do, name three or four people with genuinely opposed stakes in the matter - an investor, an accountant, a customer, a rival - and make the machine argue the question out as each of them in turn. The value is not in the advice but in the disagreement, because that is where your blind spots are sitting.
How to use The Council of Invisible Counselors in Perplexity
Be honest about what happens here: ask for four advisors and you get four paragraphs of sourced summary wearing name tags. The disagreement is not real, because nothing is arguing - it is searching. But the chapter's underlying idea survives in a better form. Instead of imagining a council, go and find the real one. Real investors have written about free tiers. Real treasurers and sanitation officers work to published rules. Real farmers and shopkeepers have been interviewed. Ask for what named people and official sources actually say, for and against, each with its link, and you have a council whose members exist. Then take that sourced brief to ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini and let the debate be staged there.
- Find the real council - named people, official rules, published prices.
- Ask for the for-and-against positions with a link against each.
- Say plainly where the evidence is thin instead of accepting a guess.
From GenAI for Everyone: Prompt Engineering Handbook, First Edition 2025, by Raja Rajeshwari Seshadri and Shreeram Iyer.
Be honest about what happens here: ask for four advisors and you get four paragraphs of sourced summary wearing name tags. The disagreement is not real, because nothing is arguing - it is searching. But the chapter's underlying idea survives in a better form. Instead of imagining a council, go and find the real one. Real investors have written about free tiers. Real treasurers and sanitation officers work to published rules. Real farmers and shopkeepers have been interviewed. Ask for what named people and official sources actually say, for and against, each with its link, and you have a council whose members exist. Then take that sourced brief to ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini and let the debate be staged there.
- Find the real council - named people, official rules, published prices.
- Ask for the for-and-against positions with a link against each.
- Say plainly where the evidence is thin instead of accepting a guess.
- Keep the sourced brief in a Space and reuse it next decision.
- Stage the debate in another tool; ask the family yourself.
Instead of
What are the benefits of a free plan?
Perplexity version
This is the research half of the job. Asking you to play four advisors would get me four sourced summaries with name tags on them, so instead find me the real council - people and documents that exist - and I will stage the debate in another tool. I run a small startup in Bengaluru whose app helps coaching centres track fees and attendance. About 40 centres pay us. I am considering a free first year for every new centre. Cite everything, and give me the date on the page you used. 1. Indian software founders who have publicly written or spoken about giving small businesses a free tier or a free year - what did they say it cost them, and which of them later withdrew it? Quote them and link the source. 2. What the Indian coaching-institute and school-ERP products charge today, and which of them advertise a free trial and of what length. Link each pricing page. 3. Anything published on free-to-paid conversion for small-business software in India specifically, not a global average borrowed from elsewhere. 4. What official Indian accounting or GST guidance says about supplying a service free of charge - valuation, input credit - citing the authority rather than a blog explaining it. Then give me one page: the four strongest sourced positions, two for and two against, each with its citation, and a short list of where the evidence is thin. Save the thread in a Space called "Pricing decision".
Then loop it
- The conversion data is thin and mostly global. Search again for Indian reporting or founder write-ups specifically, and if there is genuinely nothing reliable, say so - I would rather know the number does not exist.
- Now compress the sourced positions into a brief I can paste into another tool, where I will have the investor, the accountant, the customer and the competitor argue it out properly.
Why it worksInstead of four imagined advisors, it assembles four real sourced positions - so when the debate is staged elsewhere, each seat argues from evidence rather than from the model's guess.
Instead of
Should I move to Pune after retirement?
Perplexity version
Half of this question belongs here and half does not, so let us be clear about the split. The financial planner's half - what two cities cost, what hospitals exist, what the air is like - is sourced fact and this is the right place for it. My wife's half, my daughter's half, the friend who stayed in Dehradun - those are not research questions, and a cited paragraph pretending to be my wife's opinion would be worse than no answer at all. I will ask her myself. So: I am 66, retired from the army, on a fixed pension, living in Dehradun with my wife. Our daughter is in Pune. We are weighing a permanent move. Give me a sourced comparison, as a table wherever a table is possible, and link every figure. 1. Cost of living for a retired couple, Dehradun against Pune - rent in an ordinary residential area, domestic help, groceries, utilities. Name the year the figure is from. 2. Large multi-speciality hospitals in Pune, and which of them are empanelled under ECHS. Link the official empanelment list, not an aggregator. 3. Air quality through the year in both cities, from a monitoring authority. Note the months when either city is worst. 4. Senior-citizen services actually run by the Pune municipal corporation, and anything comparable in Dehradun. 5. Monsoon and summer temperature ranges for both, from a meteorological source. Where the data is dated or absent, say so plainly. Then list the three facts I should re-check closer to any decision.
Then loop it
- Narrow to healthcare, which is the part that worries us most. For ECHS in Pune specifically, which hospitals are currently empanelled, and what do recent reports say about how referrals and reimbursement actually work? Cite the accounts, not the policy.
- Now compress this into a one-page sourced brief on the money, the hospitals and the climate. I will take it to another tool, where my wife, my daughter and a planner can argue the rest out - and I will ask my wife directly, which no search will do for me.
Why it worksIt keeps the half of the council that can be sourced - costs, hospitals, climate - and refuses to invent the half that lives in his own family, which is the honest division of labour.
Instead of
Is switching to banana leaves good for the temple?
Perplexity version
This plan has four stakeholders whose positions are a matter of public record - the sanitation officer works to published rules, the farmer to market prices, the treasurer to real costs, and other temples have already tried this - and one, the devotee of forty years, who is not on the internet. Find me the first four. I will go and talk to the fifth. I volunteer with a temple trust in Madurai. Our ten-day festival serves annadanam to about 3,000 people a day on plastic-coated paper plates. I want to switch to banana leaves. Cite everything, and tell me the date on each page. 1. Do plastic-coated paper plates fall under the current single-use plastic rules in India, and what does Tamil Nadu's own order say? Link the rule or the notification, not a news summary of it. 2. Wholesale price of banana leaves in or near Madurai, and how it moves during festival season. Say plainly if you can only find retail or undated prices. 3. Temples, mutts, wedding halls or institutions in Tamil Nadu that have made this switch at scale - what did coverage report about supply, labour and cost? Quote and link. 4. What a municipality expects an institution to do with several hundred kilos of wet organic waste a day, and whether Madurai Corporation runs any composting or collection arrangement an institution can use. 5. Whether any Tamil Nadu scheme supports banana farmers supplying leaves, or any farmer collective near Madurai does this already. Label anything unverified. A wrong price would sink this in the committee meeting.
Then loop it
- Supply on peak days is the objection I will have to answer. Search specifically for how large kitchens or caterers in Tamil Nadu arrange banana leaf supply in bulk - advance contracts, farmer collectives, two suppliers - and cite what you find rather than describing how it could work.
- Now compress this into a sourced one-page brief - rule, price, precedent, waste arrangement - and save it in a Space called "Temple festival". I will take the brief to another tool to put the cook, treasurer and sanitation officer in a room, and I will ask the elderly devotees in person.
Why it worksGiving the critics a seat works here only if the critics are real - so it sources the rules, prices and precedents the treasurer and sanitation officer will actually cite, and leaves the devotee's voice to be heard in person.
Questions
What is The Council of Invisible Counselors in prompt engineering?
A single answer, however well written, is one point of view - and usually the most agreeable one. Instead of asking what you should do, name three or four people with genuinely opposed stakes in the matter - an investor, an accountant, a customer, a rival - and make the machine argue the question out as each of them in turn. The value is not in the advice but in the disagreement, because that is where your blind spots are sitting.
When should I use this technique?
When you have half decided something expensive or hard to reverse, and what you actually need is the strongest case against it before you commit.
How do I apply it in Perplexity?
Be honest about what happens here: ask for four advisors and you get four paragraphs of sourced summary wearing name tags. The disagreement is not real, because nothing is arguing - it is searching. But the chapter's underlying idea survives in a better form. Instead of imagining a council, go and find the real one. Real investors have written about free tiers. Real treasurers and sanitation officers work to published rules. Real farmers and shopkeepers have been interviewed. Ask for what named people and official sources actually say, for and against, each with its link, and you have a council whose members exist. Then take that sourced brief to ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini and let the debate be staged there.
What are the limits of this technique in Perplexity?
Two limits worth knowing before you try. First, it will not hold a position: tell it to argue against your plan and it reverts within a paragraph to summarising both sides, because that is what an answer engine is built to do. Second, the voices this chapter values most are often the ones with no published trace - your wife, your daughter, the elderly devotee who has eaten at the temple for forty years. No amount of searching will produce them, and a sourced paragraph standing in for your wife's opinion is worse than useless. Gather the facts here. Stage the debate elsewhere. Ask the people in your own life yourself.
How do I improve the answer after the first try?
After the first debate, check whether every counsellor actually disagreed, or whether they all politely said the same thing. If the debate feels soft, say "Make the critic tougher - give the strongest argument against." Then pick the point of greatest conflict and ask two counsellors to argue it out. Finally, ask for a synthesis: "Where do they agree, and what is the wisest path?" Save a council you like, so you can call the same experts again next time.
Loop it
After the first debate, check whether every counsellor actually disagreed, or whether they all politely said the same thing. If the debate feels soft, say "Make the critic tougher - give the strongest argument against." Then pick the point of greatest conflict and ask two counsellors to argue it out. Finally, ask for a synthesis: "Where do they agree, and what is the wisest path?" Save a council you like, so you can call the same experts again next time.
This lesson on the other tools
The technique is the same; the way you write it is not. ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini.